Keeping Secrets

In Congress, one person may have reasons to keep information private, while another has equally compelling reasons to make it public. In 1844, as the volatile issue of slavery inflamed emotions, Senator Benjamin Tappan of Ohio gave a secret treaty to a journalist. He wanted to publicize sections of the treaty that would allow slavery in Texas.

The Senate censured Tappan and threatened to expel future members who "leaked," or revealed, secrets.

Four years later, someone in the Senate gave the still-secret Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, ending the Mexican War, to New York Herald reporter John Nugent. Determined to make good on its threat to enforce secrecy, the Senate ordered Nugent imprisoned in the Capitol until he named his source. Nugent refused. A frustrated Senate eventually released the reporter without discovering his source.

History of Congress and the Capitol

The Senate 1815-1851

Next Image Next Image Previous Image Previous Image
Benjamin Tappan, by P. E. Reason,...
Image Caption

Benjamin Tappan, by P. E. Reason, after a painting by Blanchard, 1840

Benjamin Tappan, by P. E. Reason, after a painting by Blanchard, 1840

Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress

Benjamin Tappan, by P. E. Reason, after a painting by Blanchard, 1840

Benjamin Tappan, by P. E. Reason, after a painting by Blanchard, 1840

Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress

Pages