Senate tally sheet on nomination of John Rutledge as chief justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, December 15, 1795
On December 15, 1795, the Senate rejected John Rutledge with a vote of 10–14. It was the first time the Senate ever rejected a president’s Supreme Court nominee. Rutledge remains the shortest-serving chief justice of the Supreme Court. With the Senate’s consent, President George Washington appointed Senator Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut as Rutledge’s successor.
Records of the U.S. Senate, National Archives and Records Administration
The Senate Rejects a Chief Justice
While Congress was in recess in 1795, President George Washington appointed a successor to resigning Chief Justice John Jay. Washington chose John Rutledge, who sought the position and had briefly served as an associate justice. Before the Senate reconvened, Rutledge made a speech harshly criticizing Jay and the president. When the Senate met to exercise its power of advice and consent, it rejected Rutledge because of his political activity. It was the Senate’s first rejection of a Supreme Court nominee.
Presidential appointments of Supreme Court justices require the Senate’s advice and consent. The Senate withheld its consent to a Supreme Court nomination for the first time in 1795.